42: PICCADILLY INCIDENT

Still: PICCADILLY INCIDENT

All images are the copyright of their respective rightsholder and may not be reproduced from this site without permission of the rightsholder.

Great Britain 1946 Dir Herbert WILCOX

(Year refers to British release)

Running Time: 102 minutes
Black/White

Estimated Attendance: 11.5 million

View cast and credits

What they said at the time...

Synopsis

Drama. Wren Diana Fraser meets Captain Alan Pearson by chance during an air-raid in London. They marry and spend her short embarkation leave together, but their hopes are tragically destroyed when, after the fall of Singapore, she is reported missing at sea. Alan, cruelly hurt and lonely, some three years later marries for a second time. Meanwhile Diana, cast up on a desert island with five other survivors, is clinging to life despite the boredom, frustration and hardships, sustained by her hope of eventually returning to her husband. When she finally is taken home, she is stunned to find him happily married to another woman, with a little son. Loving Alan and realising that her return is a disaster for all of them, she tries to pretend that she no longer loves him and wants a divorce. The problem is solved by her death in another air-raid, and Alan is able to legalise his second marriage. The picture ends on the bitter thought that according to English law nothing can legalise the position of the baby, who will always be subject to the penalties, both legal and social, of illegitimacy

Review

The serious intention of the film is confined to the prologue and epilogue, in which a weighty legal view is ponderously delivered of the injustice suffered by illegitimate children. In between, it is a normal human drama, with a beginning which is unquestionably more convincing than the end. The opening scenes which take place in blitzed London are authentic, and dialogue, direction and acting all combine to make the characterisations by Michael Wilding and Anna Neagle unusually true to life. Up to the depressing parting in early morning Waterloo Station, all goes quietly but well. But with Diana's departure for Singapore the story becomes more fanciful. Scenes at home remain credible, but the desert island existence of Diana and her colleagues, though done with a commendable lack of glamour, is a little harder to believe. With her return to England both Diana and Alan cease to behave like real people at all, and the happy coincidence by which the falling wall kills her rather than him is altogether too much like a trick ending. It remains quite an entertaining film, and the social problem involved will probably interest people without scaring them by being driven home too deliberately, but it certainly seems a pity that so promising a beginning should have tailed off to such an unsatisfactory ending.

Synopsis and Review from Monthly Film Bulletin Vol.13 No.153 p.122 1946

The Monthly Film Bulletin was published by the BFI between 1934 and 1991. Initially aimed at distributors and exhibitors as well as filmgoers, it carried reviews and details of all UK film releases. In 1991, the Bulletin was incoporated into Sight and Sound magazine.

Last Updated: 12 Jun 2009