Close-up (1989)

The more ‘information’ we’re offered about the case, the more we come to realise that there are no easy answers to any of the questions being raised.

From the mid-1990s until his death in 2016, Abbas Kiarostami was widely regarded as one of the most original, innovative and important filmmakers around, an audacious, idiosyncratic artist with a profoundly humane but highly distinctive view of the world. Close-Up is often seen not only as a turning-point in the Iranian’s career – it cemented his confidence in blurring the distinction between ‘documentary’ and ‘fiction’ – but as the film most representative of his aims and achievements.

It could have been a straightforward record of the court case of an unemployed print worker accused of impersonating filmmaker Mohsen Makhmalbaf with the intent of fraudulently obtaining money from a well-to-do family. But in relating the story of Hossein Sabzian’s encounter with the Ahankhahs, Kiarostami characteristically opts for anything but an obvious linear narrative. Mixing 16mm footage of the trial (in which Kiarostami himself seems to ask as many questions as the judge) with recreations of events performed by the family, Sabzian and others playing themselves, he fragments the story into diverse meandering strands that frequently frustrate expectations while still remaining intelligible and engrossing. ‘Important’ events may be left unseen; in their place, sequences in which nothing of any clear consequence happens. Re-enactments occur without giving away whose point of view they represent. The more ‘information’ we’re offered about the case, the more we come to realise that there are no easy answers to any of the questions being raised. The plot thickens – except that we do, eventually, understand that the accused, for all his strange, seemingly unmotivated deceptions, is undoubtedly a decent human being, worthy of our attention, sympathy and respect.

Though formally inventive, Close-Up confirms that its creator is no formalist. The film is driven both by deep, unsentimental compassion and by genuine philosophical curiosity; it explores the fraught relationships between truth and falsehood, film and ‘reality’, intention and action, and acknowledges, from start to finish, the role and responsibility of the director in his engagement with the people in his film. Also admirably typical of Kiarostami’s best work is his admission – indeed, insistence – that the film is incomplete until viewers respond by engaging with its artifice and actively using their imaginations. For Kiarostami, the unshown, the unsaid, the unknown were crucially important; meaning was inextricably linked to mystery.

Geoff Andrew

1989 Iran
Directed by
Abbas Kiarostami
Written by
Abbas Kiarostami
Featuring
Hossein Sabziyan, Mohsen Makhmalbaf, Abolfazl Ahankhah
Running time
100 minutes

Ranked in The Greatest Films of All Time poll

Sight and Sound

Who voted for Close-up

Critics

Jon Asp
Sweden
Nicholas Baer
Netherlands
Annie Berke
USA
Eddie Bertozzi
Italy
Moinak Biswas
India
Camille Blot-Wellens
France/Sweden
Rasmus Brendstrup
Denmark
José Cabrera
Spain
Kambole Campbell
UK
Karen Chan
Singapore
Tom Charity
Canada/UK
Phoebe Chen
China/Australia
Godfrey Cheshire
USA
Jake Cole
USA
Adam Cook
Canada
Nilo Couret
USA
Kevin Coyne
Ireland
Agnes Devictor
France
André Dias
Portugal
Flavia Dima
Romania
David Ehrlich
USA
Miquel Escudero Diéguez
Spain/Chile/France
Swarnavel Eswaran Pillai
USA
Arman Fatić
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Elsa Fernández-Santos
Spain
Jean-Michel Frodon
France
Adriano Garrett
Brazil
Devika Girish
USA/India
Ed Gonzalez
USA
Aswathy Gopalakrishnan
India
Belinda van de Graaf
Netherlands
Tim Grierson
USA
Bruno Guaraná
United States
Mara Guevara
Argentina
Victor Guimarães
Brazil
Evgeny Gusyatinskiy
Netherlands
Malte Hagener
Germany
Rahul Hamid
US
Arnaud Hée
France
Jenny Horwell
UK
Javier Ikaz
Spain
Bruce Jenkins
USA
Robert Koehler
USA
Kaarel Kuurmaa
Estonia
Alisa Lebow
UK
Joachim Lepastier
France
Diego Lerer
Argentina
Zhang Ling
China
Giovanni Marchini Camia
Italy/Switzerland/Germany
Ivone Margulies
USA
Eva Markovits
France
Carlos Alberto Mattos
Brazil
Brian Meacham
USA
Karsten Meinich
Norway
Benjamin Mercer
USA
Veton Nurkollari
Kosovo
Hugo Obregón
Spain
Darcy Paquet
USA
Višnja Pentić Vukašinović
Croatia
Xavier Pillai
UK
Adam Piron
USA
Simon Popek
Slovenia
Ivan Ramljak
Croatia
Kong Rithdee
Thailand
Sebastián Rosal
Argentina
Peter Christian Rude
Denmark
Caspar Salmon
UK
Ariel Schweitzer
France/Israel
Meenakshi Shedde
India
Dana Stevens
USA
Eternality Tan
Singapore
Mark Toscano
USA
Susana Viegas
Portugal
K. F. Watanabe
USA
Jon Wengström
Sweden
Genevieve Yue
USA
Iván Zgaib
Argentina
Matt Zoller Seitz
USA

Directors

Ali Abbasi
Denmark
María Aparicio
Argentina
Jerónimo Atehortúa
Colombia
Anthony Chen
Singapore
Denis Coté
Canada
David Easteal
Australia
Homer Etminani
Colombia/Spain
Martín Farina
Argentina
Libertad Gills
Ecuador
Srdan Golubović
Serbia
Sawandi Groskind
Finland
Varun Grover
India
Mahamat-Saleh Haroun
Chad
Natesh Hegde
India
Annemarie Jacir
Palestine
Kirsten Johnson
USA
Carlos Marqués-Marcet
Spain
Shahram Mokri
Iran
Tadhg O'Sullivan
Ireland
Asli Özge
Turkey
Panah Panahi
Iran
Ben Reed
UK
Sophy Romvari
Canada
Alonso Ruizpalacios
Mexico
Josh Safdie
USA
Luke Seomore
UK
Kazuhiro Soda
Japan
Anocha Suwichakornpong
Thailand
Chaitanya Tamhane
India
Sami Tlili
Tunisia
Pimpaka Towira
Thailand
Laura Waddington
UK
Ezequiel Yanco
Argentina

Articles related to Close-up

The Greatest Films of All Time

The Greatest Films of All Time

The Greatest Films of All Time
The Greatest Films of All Time

Directors’ 100 Greatest Films of All Time

Directors’ 100 Greatest Films of All Time
Lists

90 great films of the 1990s

By Peter Hill, David Jenkins and others

90 great films of the 1990s
Load more