Hayley Scanlon

Freelance film writer; editor, Windows on Worlds
UK

Voted for

FilmYearDirector
MINATO NO NIHON MUSUME1933Hiroshi Shimizu
ZANGIKU MONOGATARI1939Kenji Mizoguchi
I, the Executioner1968Tai Kato
SHO O SUTEYO, MACHI E DEYO (THROW AWAY YOUR BOOKS, LET'S GO INTO THE STREETS)1971Shuji Terayama
UNI TO DOKUYAKU1987Kei Kumai
My Heart Is That Eternal Rose1989Patrick Tam
BLACK SNOW1989Xie Fei
Jin-Roh1999Hiroyuki Okiura
Peppermint Candy1999Lee Chang-dong
Diqiu zuihou de yewan2018Bi Gan

Comments

MINATO NO NIHON MUSUME

1933 Japan

A melancholy romantic melodrama of globalising pre-war Japan, Hiroshi Shimizu’s late silent masterpiece features striking visual technique, along with some of the best intertitles ever committed to screen.

ZANGIKU MONOGATARI

1939 Japan

Kenji Mizoguchi’s late 19th-century tale of an arrogant actor’s path to professional success and personal redemption, bought for him by the self-sacrificing servant girl his family forbid him to marry, is endlessly heartbreaking.

I, the Executioner

1968

Tai Kato's little seen serial-killer thriller, co-scripted by none other than Yoji Yamada, is a grimy investigation of post-war morality that arrives with serious menace and a proto-giallo sensibility, all tied together by Kato’s characteristic visual flair.

SHO O SUTEYO, MACHI E DEYO (THROW AWAY YOUR BOOKS, LET'S GO INTO THE STREETS)

1971

A tale of post-war alienation, Shuji Terayama’s anarchic, avant-garde masterpiece defies explanation but embodies a spirit of pure rebellion.

UNI TO DOKUYAKU

1987 Japan

Kei Kumai’s films often dealt with controversial subjects, and this strikingly composed adaptation of a Shusaku Endo novel is no exception in its chilling exploration of the depths of human cruelty.

My Heart Is That Eternal Rose

1989

An achingly beautiful take on heroic bloodshed by Patrick Tam, in which the gangster society conspires to destroy love in all its forms.

BLACK SNOW

1989 People's Republic of China

Featuring a heartbreaking performance by Jiang Wen, Xei Fei’s noirish tale of loneliness and despair is a profoundly moving exploration of displacement and futility in post-Tiananmen China.

Jin-Roh

1999

Beautifully drawn and emotionally devastating, Okiura’s uncompromising animation is an infinitely bleak tale of the destructive and dehumanising quality of authoritarianism.

Peppermint Candy

1999

In Lee’s fatalistic tale of one man’s slow-burn destruction stands in for that of his nation, peppermint candy becomes a poignant symbol of ruined innocence.

Diqiu zuihou de yewan

2018 People's Republic of China, France, Germany, Qatar

Bi Gan’s mesmerising, neon-lit romantic noir features a 59-minute single take in 3D but captivates with its intensely melancholy atmosphere of irresolvable longing and frustrated desire.

Further remarks

The film I most regret omitting is Hou Hsiao-hsien’s Three Times, which I’d have loved to include for its wonderful opening sequence. There are many other films which I might have chosen and whose absence I miss, but really the list is endless. These are 10 which in their own way speak to the infinite possibilities of cinema.