Prima Facie: Cynthia Erivo gives a towering performance in an overly literal adaptation of the successful one-woman show
Fast-paced editing and a clunky voiceover flatten the impact of playwright Suzie Miller’s legal drama, but Cynthia Erivo rises above its flaws.

Theatre is not cinema’s rival and yet ‘theatrical’ is often used as a pejorative when applied to film, while calling a stage production ‘cinematic’ can only be flattering. Susanna White’s Prima Facie challenges this implied hierarchy by translating the widely popular NT Live one-woman-show of the same name to the narrative conventions of cinema with a script adapted by playwright Suzie Miller herself. The result is a tame legal drama led by a blistering performance from Cynthia Erivo.
Tessa Ensler (Erivo) is a barrister who hasn’t lost a case in months. Her slick ponytail, permed lashes and sequin heels make her stand out as she marches through the Old Bailey, as if being a Black, working-class woman in a sea of white male privilege wasn’t enough. She is brilliant and admired by all, not least the top-dog lawyer in her chambers, Julian (Daniel Ings). But in Tessa’s world, the stark division between ‘I’ and ‘them’ – the “thoroughbreds on the starting gate” – never goes away. That equestrian metaphor opens Miller’s play, but the film fleshes it out as a dizzying montage of horses clicking and neighing. It exemplifies the kind of adaptation Prima Facie is: a tad too literal. Such an approach to a play written in the wake of #MeToo risks flattening its urgency into a palatable narrative structure.
Tessa’s core monologue – on stage both action and exposition – is reduced in favour of fast-paced editing, and Isobel Waller-Bridge’s enveloping score, all guided by a self-reflexive voiceover. Despite the restraints, Erivo shines in a consistently high-strung performance as a woman of fierce determination, in the vein of Harriet (2019) and Drift (2023).
When she takes the stand as a victim of abuse – no silk, no wig, no armour – it is her complexity that exposes the law as unjust. Channelling Witness For the Prosecution (1954), cinematographer Mike Eley relies on eyeline-match close-ups and wide shots, before zooming in on Tessa with tensely low angles and rack focus to show how a fragmented memory feels. A coat of anxious, high-pitched ringing spreads over flashbacks so the audience too can feel pummelled by the victim-blaming couched as “reasonable to assume,” as per the film’s title. One takes solace in knowing that where justice fails, women persevere, but in this docile adaptation, Erivo is fighting a lonely battle, just like her character.
► Prima Facie is in UK cinemas now.
The new issue of Sight and Sound
On the cover: Godzilla, from Gojira to Minus Zero: an interview with director Yamazaki Takashi, plus a look at the monster’s 70 years in film. Inside: The editors of the Black Film Bulletin look back on the cultural changes witnessed since the publication began, Diane Morgan and Charlie Brooker talk Cunk on cinema, Lance Oppenheim discusses Primetime, Lee Chang-dong on Possible Love, Los Javis on La bola negra, Quentin Tarantino watches Brian De Palma’s Murder à la Mod and 20 years after its release, we revisit Andrea Arnold’s Red Road.
Get your copy