You Can See Everything: seeing isn’t believing in Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s slippery Elizabeth Holmes documentary

Taking convicted fraudster Elizabeth Holmes’s insistence upon her innocence as a starting point, Fielder and Oppenheim craft an unsettling portrait of the former Theranos CEO in which truth, identity and accountability are wobbly concepts.

Elizabeth Holmes in You Can See Everything (2026)

“They’re not playing me. They’re playing a character I created.” So said Elizabeth Holmes, the disgraced founder of Theranos Inc., when asked by a New York Times journalist about Amanda Seyfried (who played her in an Emmy-winning TV miniseries) and Jennifer Lawrence (who nearly played her in a feature film). Or did she? In Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s compelling, troubling documentary You Can See Everything, Holmes claims that the quote was manufactured wholesale by the reporter, and that this yet another example of her being used as a dehumanised cog in someone else’s narrative. She is adamant that she would never make such a statement.

Or… is she? Lurking behind Holmes in most scenes, and eager to speak on her behalf, is Billy Evans, her partner since 2018. He claims to have his own recordings of all of Holmes’ recent interviews, including the one in question, but declines to produce them for Fielder. Fielder later contacts the reporter, who stands by the story but also doesn’t produce evidence. This stalemate is emblematic of the film, which hovers for almost three hours on the verge of cracking its subject before wondering if she has a self to crack.

Whether or not Holmes actually said those words, few observers would argue their substance. After launching Theranos in 2003 when she was just 19, Holmes spent the next 15 years playing a cartoon version of a Silicon Valley CEO. She wore black turtlenecks like Steve Jobs, spoke in an affected low-register voice, and never missed an opportunity to pose for magazine covers. Her signature product was a machine called the Edison that could allegedly perform hundreds of complex medical tests with just one pinprick of blood. This “iPod for healthcare” generated so much excitement and investment that it spent several years on the market before it was exposed as a fraud. Investigative journalism revealed that the Edison relied on mostly pre-existing technology that diluted blood samples, delivering wildly inaccurate results. A $9 billion company plummeted to zero practically overnight, and Holmes was eventually convicted of defrauding investors.

You Can See Everything (2026)

Holmes’ story was previously told in Alex Gibney’s documentary The Inventor: Out for Blood in Silicon Valley (2019), which framed her as a master manipulator who gamed Silicon Valley. Cannily playing the role of a girlboss wunderkind, she courted the likes of Henry Kissinger and George Shultz as board members – powerful, deep-pocketed men without a science background. “Fake it ‘til you make it” appeared to be Holmes’s ethos – and in the tech sector, it’s hardly an uncommon one. You may remember that Danny Boyle and Aaron Sorkin’s admiring biopic Steve Jobs (2015) contained a scene where Jobs cheerfully admits several minutes before a product launch that his team hasn’t actually figured out the technology yet, just the design. And what’s the status of Elon Musk’s oft-promised Mars colony, anyway?

Gibney’s documentary took as given that Holmes was a con artist, and indicted the system that enabled her. Fielder and Oppenheim take as their starting point Holmes’ extraordinary insistence that she is innocent. According to her, the Edison worked exactly as she described it, and actually can run more than 100 medical tests… but perhaps not all at the same time, and perhaps not if the inputs are inadequate. She claims she has never told a lie – not in business, and not even in her life. The “fraud” was all a big misunderstanding; to quote Holmes’ onetime admirer Bill Clinton, it just depends on what your definition of “is” is.

Just as you’re saying, “Oh, come on…” Fielder entertains the notion by showing Holmes a clip of Abbott & Costello performing “Who’s on First.” She smiles blankly, apparently not getting the joke. From the self-made billionaire of the early 2010s, Holmes has devolved into a helpless naif who can’t even understand wordplay. If this new Holmes is just another character, then she never breaks it. Fielder, so unflappably deadpan on his comic documentary shows Nathan for You (2013-17) and The Rehearsal (2022-25), has finally met his match. For the first time, he is forced to adjust his screen presence to something approaching “normal.”

You Can See Everything (2026)

Can this possibly be the same person who bestrode Silicon Valley like a Colossus? Holmes’ father suggests that the Theranos-era Holmes was a traumatised person moulded by her then-boyfriend and business partner Ramesh “Sunny” Balwani. Nowadays, Holmes professes a happy willingness to subsume her identity into her current partner’s. Typical of Billy Evans’ overbearing presence is an early scene where pulls a bowl of eggs from her hands to show how to properly scramble them. Evans entered Holmes’ life around the time her empire fell apart, which Fielder registers with suspicion. Days before reporting to prison, she and Evans are busy planning Theranos 2.0 as if nothing has ever happened.

The first part of the film takes place in 2023 in the month before the start of her 11-year sentence. Then, Fielder and Oppenheim pick up two years later, discovering that while Holmes is incommunicado, Evans creates tacky A.I. content of his incarcerated partner and posts freely on her Twitter/X account. The filmmakers rightly view him with disdain, but provocatively put his actions in conversation with Amanda Seyfried’s acclaimed portrayal (which clearly wounded Holmes) and their own film, asking to what extent these media depictions become arbiters of – or substitutes for – the truth.

At several points, Fielder wonders if Holmes really believes what she says, or if she is the most manipulative person of all time. One thing that’s unambiguous: Theranos misled and misdiagnosed many rank-and-file customers. Whether Holmes sincerely believes what she says, she is certainly guilty of selective blindness – and in offloading responsibility to Ramesh “Sunny” Balwani and Billy Evans whenever necessary. She would be an easy and deserved target for scorn, but here she goes toe-to-toe with Fielder and Oppenheim – two of the cleverest, most media-savvy minds in the business – and emerges triumphant. An unsettling takeaway: truth belongs to whoever believes it the most.

► You Can See Everything is in UK cinemas 20 November.

The new issue of Sight and Sound

On the cover: Godzilla, from Gojira to Minus Zero: an interview with director Yamazaki Takashi, plus a look at the monster’s 70 years in film. Inside: The editors of the Black Film Bulletin look back on the cultural changes witnessed since the publication began, Diane Morgan and Charlie Brooker talk Cunk on cinema, Lance Oppenheim discusses Primetime, Lee Chang-dong on Possible Love, Los Javis on La bola negra, Quentin Tarantino watches Brian De Palma’s Murder à la Mod and 20 years after its release, we revisit Andrea Arnold’s Red Road.

Get your copy