The New Mutants review: X-Men spinoff traps super-teens in a haunted house horror

This franchise offshoot shifts to a darker tone in a pared-back, female-led story that centres creepy scares and relatable characters.

7 September 2020

By Kim Newman

The New Mutants (2020)
Sight and Sound

▶︎ The New Mutants is in UK cinemas.

An (almost appropriately) orphaned offshoot of the 20th Century Fox X-Men franchise, Josh Boone’s The New Mutants has been held up for several years and arrives after corporate mergers have consigned it to a shut-down alternate universe. Marvel’s mutant properties are on hold awaiting reboot as part of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and this was always a pendant to the series which began with Bryan Singer’s X-Men (1999).

Conscious of impending doom, Fox – a name now chiselled off the famous 20th Century logo after 85 years on it – had a policy of risk-taking with this comic book property, which yielded sports like Deadpool, Logan and the TV show Legion, alongside the more standardised spin-off The Gifted. The Deadpool and Wolverine films, and even Legion, focus on superheroic male self-pity; this interestingly skews younger and female – which could well explain the studio’s iffiness on the project, as well as the hostility from a certain segment of the fanboy media.

Picking up a thread flapping since the after-the-credits tag of X-Men Apocalypse (2016), The New Mutants adapts an X-Men spin-off comic created in 1982 by writer Chris Claremont and artist Bob McLeod (though specifically drawing on the ‘Demon Bear’ arc, illustrated by Bill Sienkewicz).

Anya Taylor-Joy as Illyana Rasputin

Cannily, Boone and co-writer Knate Lee make a key premise change that shifts to a darker tone. A long way from being a traditional superhero movie, this is closer in tone to teen-themed horror films like the Elm Street franchise – especially A Nightmare on Elm Street III: Dream Warriors (1987) – or the earlier Anya Taylor-Joy vehicle Morgan (2016). A group of superkids with uncontrollable abilities are confined in a mansion a lot less cosy than Professor Xavier’s school with their worst fears manifested as creepypasta bogeymen or deep-fried dead relatives.

While bigger franchise films are timid about inclusivity – hinting that supporting characters might be gay in scenes that can’t be edited for the Chinese release – this admirably allows Cheyenne dreamweaver Blu Hunt and Scots werewolf Maisie Williams to have the beginnings of a relationship which is the emotional core of the (very female-led) film but not its focus. Taylor-Joy’s ‘mean girl’ Russian witch, a survivor of horrific abuse whose ‘happy place’ is apparently Hell, runs off with the film, sniping nastily via a glove puppet dragon and producing a magic sword from her arm when she has to go up against a CGI incarnation of Sienkewicz’s scratchy demon bear.

While on hold, the film seems to have been pared back – which works to its advantage. The team-up-against-a-monster finale isn’t as overblown as, say, the finish of Apocalypse, allowing relatable character drama – always the heart of Claremont’s redefining work on X-Men comics – to register.

Other things to explore


Trenque Lauquen: an epic hymn to the unclassifiable

By Arjun Sajip

Trenque Lauquen: an epic hymn to the unclassifiable

Anselm: Wim Wenders’s innovative 3D documentary immerses the viewer in the art of Anselm Kiefer

By Katie McCabe

Anselm: Wim Wenders’s innovative 3D documentary immerses the viewer in the art of Anselm Kiefer
From the Sight and Sound archive

‘Horrifyingly graphic’ Saving Private Ryan reviewed in 1998

By John Wrathall

‘Horrifyingly graphic’ Saving Private Ryan reviewed in 1998